Customized for your search:

Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York

Shelter Island Heights hotels
Shelter Island Heights

Choose from 4 Shelter Island Heights Hotel Deals

The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island Heights Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

The Pridwin Hotel

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights - Map
"Off season stay."
Great place to stay off season. Staff very pleasant. This place has some great old time character.
Paul from Hamburg, NY
Situated near the bay, this hotel is within a 10-minute walk of Shelter Island Tennis Club and Crescent Beach. Shelter Island …More
The Chequit Inn - Shelter Island Heights Hotels
Rating: 4.0 Stars

The Chequit Inn

23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights - Map
"great place would go back"
staff is very kind and hospitable breakfast buffet is delicious
A Traveller
Situated by the ocean, this inn is within 1 mi (2 km) of Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor. Crescent Beach and …More
Shelter Island House - Shelter Island Heights Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars

Shelter Island House

11 Stearns Point Rd, Shelter Island Heights - Map
"Beautiful hotel, surrounded by nature"
We went there off season, so i could not talk about the property when completely booked. The location is gorgeous, the hotel is bright, surrounded by gardens, woods and a beautiful beach a block away. We loved our room which faced the pool. Even though it was the middle of October it got a little too warm, since the sun shone into it most of the day. This could be a plus or an issue, depending on what you like. Bathrooms are clean and well equipped, no in-room coffee maker but it is available downstairs since early morning - and it is really good. Breakfasts are no frills, toast, pastries, cereal, fruit and yogurt. There isn't really anything wrong with this place, but it does feel more like an inn than a hotel. Beds could be more comfortable, they are the old type spring frame ones, they are creaky and somewhat uncomfortable.
Traveller from US
Situated near the beach, this hotel is within a 15-minute walk of Shelter Island Country Club and Crescent Beach. Shelter …More
SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House - Shelter Island Heights Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars

SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House

7 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights - Map
"Great stay at Seven!"
Seven is welcoming like a home, but spacious enough to give everyone privacy. Rooms are super up to date, extremely clean and cheery! Overall a great experience - orange juice at breakfast is amazing!
Traveller from Hockessin, DE
Situated by the ocean, this bed & breakfast is within a 15-minute walk of Shelter Island Country Club and Crescent Beach …More

Search from 4 Shelter Island Heights Hotels

    Why book with Hotwire ?

    • Low Price Guarantee
    • No Hotwire Cancellation Fee
    • 91% customer satisfaction

    Shelter Island Heights is calling — find the perfect hotel

    Everyone wants to score a deal on travel, but price is just one factor to consider when booking an unforgettable hotel. Whether you’re visiting family, attending a conference or taking a well-earned vacation in Shelter Island Heights, having an awesome experience should be a no-brainer.

    Hotwire will hook you up! From restful nights near your flight to that prime spot in the city’s heart, we’ve done our research to bring the best options to your fingertips. Book your Shelter Island Heights hotel with us now and start your next adventure.

    You’re not the average traveler — and we know it

    You’ve done your homework and know exactly where you want to go. We’re here to help with some Hotwire travel geek-approved tips on how to save on your booking.

    Get away for the weekend

    Hotels in bigger cities usually charge higher rates during the week, when people are traveling for business. Weekends can be a bargain! It’s the other way around for vacation spots, so if you’re looking for a beach escape, consider a mid-week trip.

    Give yourself some wiggle room

    If your plans are flexible, play around with some different travel dates – a shift of a few days either way can help you save big. Prices usually jump the weekends before and after popular holidays, so we recommend steering clear of them. Or consider visiting during the off-season, when prices are generally lower.

    Plan around big events

    Are prices surprisingly high? There might be a huge conference or festival in town. Consider shifting your dates if you can. Of course, if that’s why you’re going, you’ll have to bite the bullet. We’ll still work to get you the best rates out there.

    Noodle over new adventures

    Set aside time to plan what you want to see, taste and discover. Nothing completes a trip, big or small, like a few new experiences! Check city apps or area websites to find out what’s new and what events are happening during your stay. Even during a family reunion, you can detour to that locals-only fish taco stand or under-the-radar music club. Your cousins will be impressed.