Search Deals on

Coldwater Vacation Packages

The dirtiest Hotel in America

I have stayed at a dozen properties around Put In Bay and I can say without a doubt, the Anchor Inn is the best place I have found. Close to downtown, reasonably priced for the quality and service, cleanliness of the room and property, quality of the breakfast and food offerings, thoughtful touches throughout the room and lobby. This place has spoiled us for staying anywhere else on the island. High end toiletries and bathroom amenities, Nespresso machine in every room, bathrobes, slippers, towel warmers, turn down service with chocolates and drapes darkening the room, luggage taken to your room, amazing high quality breakfast. These are some of the features this property offers. There is also a golf cart rental across the street and you are only a block from the west end of town.

Nice place. Quiet. I appreciated the breakfast- typical free breakfast. Nice game room. Had a room by pool. The window opened to the pool area- so I wasn’t able to keep our curtains open. Smelled like chlorine in room. The facility was cute. I would stay again just ask for a different room.

Rooms are clean. Hot shower. Nice clean pool. Comfy bed. Staff are very friendly. Convenient location for the event we were attending. Been staying there for years. Will be r3turning next dummer.