Search Deals on

Cat Cays Vacation Packages

I’ll be honest. I bet this place was something special a few years ago. But… it’s dated and needs serious attention. Rooms were decent, but ours had plumbing issues. There were a couple of staff members that were really kind and helpful, but most could care less. Especially the bartenders. No hospitality whatsoever. The beaches and the dolphins are the only things the island has to offer. The people are poor, and seemed high most of the time. Most acted as though they prefer we not visit.

My stay at Bimini Big Game Club from July 3–5, 2026 was excellent overall. The property is clean, well maintained, comfortable, and very welcoming. The staff was friendly, professional, and always willing to help. Whenever we needed towels or anything else, they responded quickly and provided great service. The island itself is beautiful, with amazing beaches and a relaxing atmosphere. I would definitely recommend this hotel and would consider staying here again. The only issue I experienced was during check-in. When I booked through Expedia, the reservation clearly stated that I would only need to pay a $92 resort fee at the hotel. However, when I arrived, I was charged $184 instead. The front desk staff explained that those were the correct resort fees and that they did not know why Expedia showed only $92. This was disappointing because it resulted in an unexpected extra charge that was not disclosed during the booking process. Aside from that issue, everything else was excellent, and we truly enjoyed our stay.