6/10 Okay
Christina
Traveled with partner
Feb 26, 2026
Liked: Cleanliness, amenities
Disliked: Property conditions & facilities
Conch Key Fishing Lodge was in a good location convenient to Marathon, however it is very dated on the outside. We stayed in room 6 and it was updated and nicely decorated but also worn. The floors were laminate and appeared to be nice but also shifted and made noise when walking across them. The bathroom was quite small and the shower was a round tube corner type with terrible water pressure. The grounds on the property were older and in need of cleaning up and maintenance. The location is close to the road and can be noisy so be aware if you are looking for a quiet, serene location, this is not it.
Check in was easy. I did call the phone number texted to me twice. Once for the WIFI password, which would have been nice to have in a book or note in the room so I didn't have to call. Second time, I called for TP and towels. They did deliver them right away so I was grateful for the quick service.
Overall the bed was comfortable and we were happy with the AC units and other amenities (fridge, coffee maker, etc.) however I don't think we would stay here again. It just did not live up to our expectations for a vacation stay and experience. The pics and description online did not live up to expectations with this one.

Christina
Stayed 6 nights in Feb 2026






























