Beginning of main content
Customized for your search:

Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island, United States of America

Shelter Island hotels
Shelter Island

Choose from 4 Shelter Island Hotel Deals

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.0 Stars

Best Western Plus Island Palms Hotel & Marina

2051 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
"Nice Location and excellent dining"
Beautiful location, with lots to do. Rooms are fully equipped. However, very small for the amount of furniture(the door barely cleared the bed). Also, the two inch door gap on the ground, was disturbing, since it leads directly outside and there was a nice big bug under the covers(used a towel to block and had no more visitors). Question is: shouldn't that have been attended to, if paying a hefty nightly rate? Bar and grill on site was awesome...Beautiful view and the fresh fish was uniquely and creatively prepared and presented.
Traveller from Chicago, IL
This hotel is set on Shelter Island, surrounded by San Diego Bay and a private marina; Old Town is 5 miles away, and downtown …More
Humphreys Half Moon Inn - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars

Humphreys Half Moon Inn

2303 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
"We had a lovely garden view suite."
We loved the look of our room with the palm trees on the carpet. It definitely felt a tiny bit dated but it was clean and very spacious. Our suite comfortably fit all 5 of us. We were very close to the pool which my kids loved. I went to the gym one morning... It was a very tiny space with only 3 cardio machines but it wasn't busy. Overall, a very beautiful little spot.
Traveller from Priddis, Canada
Humphreys Half Moon Inn sits on 14 acres adjacent to a yacht-filled marina overlooking San Diego Bay.More
Bay Club Hotel & Marina - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 3.5 Stars

Bay Club Hotel & Marina

2131 Shelter Island Dr, San Diego - Map
"Nice hotel room with excellent bay view"
We enjoyed seeing the Navy ships going by from our Bayview room. It was close to the beach and good walking trails along the beach. The hotel is getting old and needs some updating especially the carpet. The floor in the room was fake wood linoleum and was very dirty. Should have been mopped to clean.
A Traveller
3 miles from the San Diego Airport, Bay Club Hotel & Marina is 5 miles from SeaWorld, the cruise-ship terminal, Seaport …More
Kona Kai Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort - San Diego Hotels
Rating: 4.0 Stars

Kona Kai Resort & Spa, A Noble House Resort

1551 Shelter Island Drive, San Diego - Map
Great room and view. Loved the onsite restaurant, the Vessel.
A Traveller
Situated at the tip of Shelter Island, this 8-acre resort is 6 miles (9.7 kilometers) from SeaWorld and Seaport Village …More

Search from 4 Shelter Island Hotels

    Why book with Hotwire ?

    • Low Price Guarantee
    • No Hotwire Cancellation Fee
    • 91% customer satisfaction

    Shelter Island is calling — find the perfect hotel

    Everyone wants to score a deal on travel, but price is just one factor to consider when booking an unforgettable hotel. Whether you’re visiting family, attending a conference or taking a well-earned vacation in Shelter Island, having an awesome experience should be a no-brainer.

    Hotwire will hook you up! From restful nights near your flight to that prime spot in the city’s heart, we’ve done our research to bring the best options to your fingertips. Book your Shelter Island hotel with us now and start your next adventure.

    You’re not the average traveler — and we know it

    You’ve done your homework and know exactly where you want to go. We’re here to help with some Hotwire travel geek-approved tips on how to save on your booking.

    Get away for the weekend

    Hotels in bigger cities usually charge higher rates during the week, when people are traveling for business. Weekends can be a bargain! It’s the other way around for vacation spots, so if you’re looking for a beach escape, consider a mid-week trip.

    Give yourself some wiggle room

    If your plans are flexible, play around with some different travel dates – a shift of a few days either way can help you save big. Prices usually jump the weekends before and after popular holidays, so we recommend steering clear of them. Or consider visiting during the off-season, when prices are generally lower.

    Plan around big events

    Are prices surprisingly high? There might be a huge conference or festival in town. Consider shifting your dates if you can. Of course, if that’s why you’re going, you’ll have to bite the bullet. We’ll still work to get you the best rates out there.

    Noodle over new adventures

    Set aside time to plan what you want to see, taste and discover. Nothing completes a trip, big or small, like a few new experiences! Check city apps or area websites to find out what’s new and what events are happening during your stay. Even during a family reunion, you can detour to that locals-only fish taco stand or under-the-radar music club. Your cousins will be impressed.


    Cheap hotels near Shelter Island, CA